Best Car Rental in Aruba
"Best" means different things: newest cars, most responsive service, lowest deductible, or longest track record. The highest-rated agencies in Aruba tend to be family-owned businesses where the owner is directly involved.
Examples: Top Drive (in business since 1997) and Wheels 2 Go (owners Ricky & Anky handle customers personally). When something goes wrong, accountability matters. And family operations deliver.
How to Choose
Start with your must-haves, then compare prices among agencies that meet them:
- •Arriving after 6pm? Only Jay's (9pm) and Econo (10pm) do late pickups.
- •Want zero-deductible insurance? Not all agencies offer it. Ask upfront.
- •Under 25? Mitoo accepts drivers 21+. Most others require 23-25.
What Separates Good from Great
| Factor | Why It Matters | Who Has It |
|---|---|---|
| 24/7 WhatsApp | Flat tire at 10pm? You need to reach someone. | Mitoo, Wheels 2 Go, most others |
| Years in business | Longevity = they handle problems well | Top Drive (1997), Amigo (1995) |
| Owner involvement | Family-run = personal accountability | Wheels 2 Go, Sunset, most locals |
| Fleet age | Newer cars = fewer breakdowns | GMAX, Top Drive |
| Free extras | Cooler, chairs, snorkel gear add up | Varies, ask when booking |
Track Record vs. Newer Fleet
Established Agencies
20+ years means they've handled every problem. Reputation is everything.
Newer Players
Often have newer cars and are hungry to earn your business.
Quick Reference: Who Offers What
Late Pickup (after 6pm)
Jay's until 9pm, Econo until 10pm
Hotel Delivery
Most agencies offer free hotel drop-off
Zero-Deductible CDW
Ask specifically. Not all agencies offer it
Young Drivers (21-24)
Mitoo accepts 21+, no extra fee
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you determine which agencies are best?
We don't aggregate review scores or create fake rankings. "Best" depends on what you value: newest cars, lowest deductibles, best service, or longest track record. We present the factors so you can decide.
Does expensive mean better?
Not necessarily. Some premium-priced agencies justify the cost with newer fleets and zero-deductible insurance. Others just charge more. Look at what's included in the rate, not just the headline price.
What should I prioritize when choosing an agency?
Start with your must-haves: 24/7 WhatsApp support, after-hours pickup, hotel delivery, or zero-deductible CDW. Then compare prices among agencies that meet your requirements.
How can I tell if an agency is reliable?
Look for: years in business (longer = more reliable), owner involvement (family-run agencies tend to care more), responsive WhatsApp communication, and transparent pricing with no surprise fees.
Compare All Agencies
See the full list of 9 local agencies with their specialties, hours, and what makes each one different.
View all agencies →